The runner-up in the Fiction category is Micheál Ó'Síocháin from Cork for his story 'the auld triangle'.
In third place is Meadhbh Ní Eadhra from County Galway for her story 'Friday'.
Highly commended in the fiction section are Rozz Lewis from Carlow for her story 'Pokey Out Wire', Lauren Foley from Dublin for her story 'I Don't', and Aongus Murtagh, who lives in Berlin, for his story 'He Revisited'.
The winner in the Poetry category is Deirdre Daly from Dublin for her poem 'The Maggies'.
The runner-up in the poetry section is Stephen Byrne from Galway for his poem 'Life Without Alcohol'.
In third place is Bogusia Wardein, who lives in Norway, for her poem 'Variations on my mother'.
Highly commended in the poetry section is Patrick Maddock for his poem 'To be a friend'.
Judge’s comments from Niamh Boyce:
First a word on
the over all winner - Chris Connolly’s story, ‘There's no one new around you’, showed an awareness of form usually found in
poetry and applied it to a short story. It worked because it expressed the
tensions within the story, the tensions in life to conform, to contain
something that cannot be contained.
In
the best entries the voice was spot on from the very first sentence, pulling
the reader in, and making me forget I was judging a competition. With some of
the fiction entries they fell down on story, and usually at the end, when
trying to wrap things up - that final knowing sentence revealing an author at
work. With some, there was a technical error, most likely due to a rushed entry
– and most often, it was a change in pov, revealing that some stories were
originally written from the first person and changed. One of the strongest
poems, which had me thoroughly engaged and moved, fell down on a clichéd last
line. It’s frustrating as a judge when this happens, you want good work to do
well, and love when a voice is strong and original.
Original,
we hear that so much in relation to voice – but what does it mean? While
reading these entries, it meant specific, a specific accent and place in a poem
or story, a specific subject – general descriptions of general emotions don’t
carry the same strength. It meant that even when the voice of the poem or story
was in the first person, the I, it didn’t feel like an author trying to write
good literature for a competition, but the voice of someone saying something vital
to them, something that had to be said. It is hard to pin down, but
words like authentic, heart and honest come to mind. Rhythm too, the rhythm of
the voice of the poem and story is vital, that it connects to everything else,
the theme, tone, subject. Read aloud, the winning and commended works, achieved
a flawless flow – their own personal music.
A
word on titles, in general they were awful. Weak, with a last minute
feel about them. The title allows you to direct a reader through your work. In
a poem in particular, it allows you to say something that you have not said
‘in’ the poem. This does not apply to some of the winning and commended – but
in general the titles were horrific. With such a high quality of writing, and
such strong various voices in the entries, weak titles were a constant. They
should not be an afterthought, the work deserves better, have fun, work on
them. It didn’t affect my judging I might add, it’s just a general
observation.
The
entries were of a high level, there was a lot of good writing – There are
entries that didn’t make a winning slot here, that will go on to do very
well for their authors somewhere else. It is hard to judge stories and
poems against each other; maybe it’s even morally wrong. Taste comes into it,
every judge has their likes and dislikes, for me - a preaching tone irritates
the life out of me. Competitions however do have a role, how else can we
encourage and support writers? How else can we give them that thumbs up, to say
we love what you’re doing, keep going? It is hard to keep going, to keep the
faith that this writing thing is important, worth doing. And it is. To have
gotten anywhere in this competition is an achievement, the variety and strength
of the work was absolutely inspiring. Keep going.
The shortlist from which the winners were chosen is available here.
Over The Edge would like to thank Charlie Byrne's Bookshop, Kenny's Bookshop & Gallery, ISupply Flood Street, Dock No. 1 Bar & Restaurant, Ward's Hotel, Senatory Trevor Ó'Clochairtaigh, and Clare Daly T.D. for sponsoring our competition this year.
